Hymns and Contemporary Worship >home

from Sally Morgenthaler's book Worship Evangelism

Certain church traditions may not be as offensive in the 90s as we think. In a recent study, two-thirds of the unchurched said they would prefer to come back to an "informal" church experience. What exactly an "informal experience" entails was not clear. Yet 47 percent of those surveyed also indicated that they would like to sing some traditional hymns. (Note: This does not necessarily mean they want to sing them in a "traditional way.")

Another study found that while only 21 percent of all Americans would choose churches that offer an exclusive diet of traditional hymns, 65 percent prefer churches that provide a mix of traditional and contemporary music (music that has been composed in the last ten to twenty years). Evidently the American public -- including its vast unchurched sector -- does not support a wholesale abandonment of religious trappings.

In A Generation of Seekers, a boomer pastor speaks of the powerful emotions that are often triggered when boomers return to church and intersect with certain traditional elements in worship:

Many of my age group talk about coming to church, and they cry through the service... [especially when they listen to] the hymns, they are just unraveled. And these are people who haven't come to church in years... It's empowering... a real deep sense of coming home again... of something that was missing and then reaching some real deep places that people weren't even aware of.

Urban pastor Raphael Green tells of an interesting phenomenon he and his worship band, Urban Song, notice each summer as they present outdoor praise and worship in the parks of urban south St. Louis. For three months Green and Urban Song proclaim Christ and call upon the power of God to break spiritual strongholds within an incredibly tense, multiethnic environment. They play mostly original material and are totally at ease in the cutting-edge, urban musical styles of rhythm and blues, jazz and rap. As I heard about the extraordinary appeal of their worship events, I automatically assumed that it was the new music that was drawing crowds.

But Green surprised me. The 90s songs are not what initially attracts most of the unchurched listeners; instead, the traditional gospel tunes are the magnet. People who used to go to church suddenly hear music they have not heard for years, melodies and words reminiscent of a more secure and wholesome time -- gospel hymns and choruses that recall a closeness with God long since forgotten. Green says that it is typical for individuals in the crowd to request old favorites such as "Amazing Grace" and "The Old Rugged Cross." Granted, Urban Song does not play them quite like Aunt Bessie used to on the old church upright! But these people like what they hear.

What are we to make of this? There is widespread ignorance about the Christian faith. Yet, ironically, there seems to be an abiding memory of select worship elements. And many of the unchurched expect to reencounter at least some of them when they return to church.

Every year around the first week of November (although it does seem to be getting earlier and earlier), thoroughly Christian hits such as "Hark, the Herald Angels Sing!" and "Joy to the World" waft through malls and grocery stores. Recording artists who spend at least fifty-one weeks out of the year distancing themselves from anything remotely ancient, moral, or "church" suddenly release the most amazing renditions of several-hundred-year-old hymns. Not only does the public enjoy it, it expects it. You see, Christmas carols, just like "God Bless America" on the Fourth of July, "Amazing Grace" at funerals, and "The Wedding Song" at weddings, are part of a larger American religious lexicon, and no one, not even Santa Claus himself, dares take them away.

Copyright 1995, 1999 by Sally Morgenthaler. Used with permission.

©2008 Hearts to God